Author Archives: Jane Davidson

Pushing sand uphill with a pointy stick? ‘No value-free’ in higher ed evaluation

There’s a unique and extremely challenging barrier to singing the ‘no value-free’ parts of the genuine evaluation song in a higher education (a.k.a. tertiary education) setting. And that’s what Michael Scriven calls the value-free doctrine. Last week I delivered the … Continue reading

Posted in Education, Values-based | Tagged , , , , | 9 Comments

The real values behind ‘value-undiscussable’ evaluation

I posted yesterday about the importance of visible values in evaluation. This means being clear and transparent about the definitions of quality and value used when identifying criteria, evaluating performance against them based on evidence, and weighing up the pros … Continue reading

Posted in Evaluative questions & answers, Values-based | Tagged , | 4 Comments

“No value-free”: The importance of visible values

The “no value-free” line of the Genuine Evaluation song (composed by the incomparable Kataraina Pipi, evaluator and composer/musician, with input from several other genuine evaluators!) was inspired by an earlier post where we defined genuine evaluation and drew some lines … Continue reading

Posted in About/Definition, Evaluative rubrics, Values-based | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Does evaluator political ideology drive evaluators’ choices & approaches?

This year’s winner of the AEA Lazarsfeld award for contributions to evaluation theory, Jonny Morell, is thinking up a storm again, asking some questions that most people have just never thought of. He’s asking on his blog whether evaluators’ political … Continue reading

Posted in Values-based | 2 Comments

AEA highlights: Metaphors and more in culturally responsive evaluation

So much to see, so many choices, and today I struck gold in session after session. Here are a few highlights from one of the best! The indigenous TIG is one of the best-kept secrets at the AEA conference, and … Continue reading

Posted in Cultural context, Values-based | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment