The Friday Funny: Reasoning across cultural and gender divides

Genuine evaluation is grounded in sound evaluative reasoning and evidence to justify conclusions drawn and insights surfaced.

One of the challenges we all face in doing sound reasoning is appropriately taking into account gender and cultural perspectives.

This week’s example may not be evaluative reasoning, but it’s a humorous example of how the reasoning and evidence used and the conclusions drawn can very much hinge on experience and perspective. And, how bringing in different user perspectives can help illuminate so much more about whatever we study or evaluate.

[Source: doing the rounds on Facebook; author unknown.]

A SPANISH Teacher was explaining to her class that in Spanish, unlike English, nouns are designated as either masculine or feminine.

‘House’ for instance, is feminine: ‘la casa.’

‘Pencil,’ however, is masculine: ‘el lapiz.’

A student asked, ‘What gender is ‘computer’?’

Instead of giving the answer, the teacher split the class into two groups, male and female, and asked them to decide for themselves whether computer’ should be a masculine or a feminine noun. Each group was asked to give four reasons for its recommendation.

The men’s group decided that ‘computer’ should definitely be of the feminine gender (‘la computadora’), because:

1. No one but their creator understands their internal logic;

2. The native language they use to communicate with other computers is incomprehensible to everyone else;

3. Even the smallest mistakes are stored in long term memory for possible later retrieval; and

4. As soon as you make a commitment to one, you find yourself spending half your paycheck on accessories for it.

(THIS GETS BETTER!)

The women’s group, however, concluded that computers should be Masculine (‘el computador’), because:

1. In order to do anything with them, you have to turn them on;

2. They have a lot of data but still can’t think for themselves;

3. They are supposed to help you solve problems, But half the time they ARE the problem; and

4. As soon as you commit to one, you realize that if you had waited a little longer, you could have gotten a better model.

The women won.

Comments are closed.